RadarTrek Intel — monthly score updates
We track 40+ tools so you don't have to. Score changes, new tools, and new guides — once a month, no spam.
Password Managers comparison · 2026
1Password edges out Proton Pass in this Password Managers comparison, scoring 89 against 81 across our seven scored dimensions. Proton Pass leads on Price/Value (88 vs 65), while 1Password has the edge on Browser Extension (92 vs 80). The two are closest on Security, where the gap is just 3 points. On pricing, Proton Pass starts cheaper at $0/mo versus $3/mo. Use the radar chart and dimension table below to find which fits your specific priorities best.
Proton Pass
Privacy-first from the ProtonMail team
81/100
1Password
The gold standard for teams and families
89/100
Radar comparison
Proton Pass
81
1Password
89
Security
Encryption standard, zero-knowledge architecture, audit results
Ease of Use
Onboarding, daily UX, autofill reliability
Cross-Platform
Browser extensions, mobile apps, OS support
Price/Value
Free tier, paid tier cost vs features
Team Features
Sharing, vaults, admin controls, SSO
Import/Export
CSV import, migration tools, portability
Browser Extension
Autofill accuracy, extension speed, form detection
Overall Score
Proton Pass
Pros
Cons
1Password
Pros
Cons
Choose Proton Pass if you value security most and want a free entry point. Choose 1Password if you value security most and have budget for $3/month or more. If neither dimension is a clear priority, 1Password's higher overall score (89/100) makes it the safer default in the password managers category.
Based on our independent scoring across 7 dimensions, 1Password scores 89/100 overall versus Proton Pass's 81/100 — a 8-point margin. 1Password leads on Security in particular. That said, Proton Pass may still be the right choice if the dimensions where it scores higher match your specific priorities — the radar chart above shows the full profile side by side.
Proton Pass is cheaper at the entry level — it offers a permanent free tier, while 1Password starts at $3/month. If budget is the primary constraint, Proton Pass is the lower-risk starting point. 1Password's paid features may justify the cost — compare the plan limits before committing.
Proton Pass scores higher on Price/Value — 88/100 versus 65/100 for 1Password. If price/value is your primary decision criterion, Proton Pass is the stronger choice in this head-to-head.
Switching between password managers tools is generally possible but involves migration effort: exporting your data or configuration from Proton Pass, re-importing or reconfiguring in 1Password, and updating any API integrations or environment variables in your codebase. The effort scales with how deeply embedded the tool is in your stack. Test 1Password on a non-production project first before migrating.
Proton Pass (81/100) is the better fit for teams who prioritise security — its strongest dimension — and who want a free entry point. 1Password (89/100) is the better fit for teams who prioritise security and want a low-cost starting price. If both dimensions matter equally, the overall score winner (1Password) is the safer default choice.
Want this built for your business?
We design and build digital products — web apps, AI tools, SaaS platforms.